色花堂

Hi and welcome to the Forum.

The reason they rejected your application is explained in your post, they think yours is a marriage of convenience, that you married only to get into the EU; to quote them "You have demonstrated artificial conduct entered into solely with the purpose of obtaining the right of free movement and residence under EU law"; further, that the evidence you supplied to prove your relationship was insufficient "However, you were unable to provide sufficient evidence that you, as a family member of an EU citizen, will travel with that EU citizen to a member state or stay in a member state other than the member state of which he/she is a national. ".聽 So, you have not provided the details of where you will go to in the Netherlands, how you will get there, how you will support each other when you get there.

You need to prove that you have been in a meaningful relationship with your wife for a reasonable time (they normally want 2 years), you don't need to be married; for evidence, invoices in both your names, correspondence addressed to you both, previous housing contracts in both names.聽 You say you live in Cyprus, I assume you are legally in Cyprus and have registered there, so something perhaps from the Cypriot authorities addressed to you both.

Hope this helps.

Cynic
色花堂 Team

Hi, thank you very much for your reply.

Regarding your sentence "So, you have not provided the details of where you will go to in the Netherlands, how you will get there, how you will support each other when you get there", I have provided:
- flight tickets -> how I will get there
- her registration to the municipality where she lives -> where I will go
- how you will support each other -> this is not in the documentation requested for that type of visa.
At this point they should specify more documents to enclose in the application if the result is being rejected by providing all the docs they request, and then being told we need to provide more.聽

As for the proof of our relationship we have never lived together, except for our year of university but the contract was in my name only.
But we have flight tickets on the same dates, hotel reservations and various tickets in general.

Do you perhaps know if the application to IND can be also done if I go to NL via tourist visa?
I feel that appealing the decision will take a lot of time

Thanks a lot again for your help!

On the face of it, I accept all that you say, but I am not the IND and it is them that have made the judgements of your application and it is them you have to convince, not me.

If your wife is living in the Netherlands, then perhaps she should go to the local IND office and make enquiries there.聽 Then you will have first-hand information for any possible way to achieve your aim.聽 The IND have a contact section to their website; this will take you there.

I would not recommend you attempt to enter the Netherlands until you have this resolved; to enter on a tourist visa when your real aim is to seek to remain is against the law.

I agree. Since your wife is already legally residing and working in The Netherlands,聽 I believe she should query IND as she is in the best position and equipped to do so.

My father was also rejected with the exact same reasons. I have seen some other people here in the forum rejected on the same grounds recently.

I read somewhere that an organization called SOLVIT can help in these issues, so I contacted them to know more. I was surprised to know that IND is not really in favour of facilitation visas and tends to reject them more often.



unjustified conditions and refusals for short-term visas for non-EU family members of EU citizens in the Netherlands, Sweden, Norway, Belgium, Spain, Germany, Ireland and the UK (also reported in 2018);

Hello i was refused also before and i re applied ..i came from philippines ..what we did is we register our marriage here in netherlands and my husband sent me the paper proof that we are registered in netherlands ...and i explained in cover letter about our relationship

Hi All,

I am writing to address a situation similar to the one described above. My application was rejected on the same grounds initially. I subsequently reapplied, ensuring all the necessary documents were included, such as our lease agreement with both my partner鈥檚 and my name, my employment offer in the Netherlands, and both of our BSN appointment confirmations. Additionally, I submitted supporting documents including a detailed timeline, our previous flight ticket with both of our names, affidavits from both of our parents affirming the relationship, a letter from our estate agency assisting us with accommodation, previous cohabitation details, call and WhatsApp logs, and more.

Despite providing all the requested documentation and additional evidence, my application was rejected again, citing the same reasons as before. To my surprise, the rejection now includes allegations of 鈥渁rtificial conduct鈥� and claims that I am using this directive as a means to circumvent the process and obtain a residence permit.

I would like to clarify that all submitted documentation is entirely authentic. My partner and I have been in a committed relationship for nearly five years, and we were planning to begin our new life together in the Netherlands. This rejection has already caused significant personal and financial hardship, resulting in the loss of both my job and my accommodation, as well as substantial financial costs.

Moreover, I am concerned that this rejection, especially with the unfounded accusations, will impact my future visa applications, whether for leisure or professional purposes.

Could you kindly explain how the IND can issue such a decision, and what steps I can take to address this serious misrepresentation and potential defamation?

Thank you for your attention to this matter. I look forward to your guidance.

Hi All,I am writing to address a situation similar to the one described above. My application was rejected on the same grounds initially. I subsequently reapplied, ensuring all the necessary documents were included, such as our lease agreement with both my partner鈥檚 and my name, my employment offer in the Netherlands, and both of our BSN appointment confirmations. Additionally, I submitted supporting documents including a detailed timeline, our previous flight ticket with both of our names, affidavits from both of our parents affirming the relationship, a letter from our estate agency assisting us with accommodation, previous cohabitation details, call and WhatsApp logs, and more............................... Thank you for your attention to this matter. I look forward to your guidance.

- @brandsgooding

Hi and welcome to the Forum.

As I've said before, these kinds of things happen when the IND think they have evidence to support their decision.聽 I suspect all you can do is to appeal against the decision; the IND website tells you how to do this, and this will take you straight to the webpage with the details.

I wish you the best of luck, and I hope this helps.

Cynic

色花堂 Team